Scalping requires the right broker. You need lightning-fast execution, tight spreads, and a broker that actually allows scalping. Many don't.
We tested 12 brokers specifically for scalping and here are our top picks for US traders.
What Makes a Broker Good for Scalping?
Before the list, understand what scalpers need:
- **Tight Spreads**: Every pip matters when targeting 5-10 pip profits
- **Fast Execution**: Delays of even 100ms can kill profits
- **No Scalping Restrictions**: Some brokers prohibit or limit scalping
- **Low/No Requotes**: Requotes destroy scalping strategies
- **ECN/STP Execution**: Direct market access preferred
Best Brokers for Scalping (US Traders)
1. Coinexx - Best for ECN Scalping
Why Scalpers Love It:
- True ECN execution with 0.0 pip spreads
- Bitcoin-denominated accounts
- No scalping restrictions
- Anonymous trading option
- Fast crypto deposits/withdrawals
Spreads: From 0.0 pips + commission Execution: ECN Min. Deposit: $10
Cons: Crypto-only deposits
2. MidasFX - Best for Raw Spreads
Why Scalpers Love It:
- 0.0 pip spreads available
- Both crypto and wire transfer
- Fast withdrawals
- No scalping restrictions
Spreads: From 0.0 pips Execution: STP/ECN Min. Deposit: $1
Cons: Crypto and wire funding only
3. Hankotrade - Best for Zero Spread Accounts
Why Scalpers Love It:
- 0.0 pip raw spreads on ECN accounts
- Fast execution (under 50ms average)
- $10 minimum deposit
- US clients accepted
Spreads: From 0.0 pips + commission Execution: ECN/STP Min. Deposit: $10
Cons: Crypto-only deposits, offshore regulation
4. OANDA - Best Regulated Option
Why Scalpers Love It:
- CFTC regulated (maximum safety)
- No minimum deposit
- Flexible position sizing
- Good execution speed
Spreads: From 1.0 pips Execution: Market maker Min. Deposit: $0
Cons: Wider spreads than offshore options, 1:50 max leverage
5. Forex.com - Best for Active Scalpers
Why Scalpers Love It:
- CFTC regulated
- Active trader rebates (reduce costs)
Free: US Forex Trading Checklist
Don't start trading without this 20+ item checklist. Covers broker verification, account setup, and compliance essentials.
- MT4 and MT5 available
- Research tools for analysis
Spreads: From 0.8 pips Execution: STP Min. Deposit: $100
Cons: Requires higher volume for best rebates
Scalping Broker Comparison Table
| Broker | Spreads | Execution | Min. Deposit | Scalping Allowed | US Clients | |--------|---------|-----------|--------------|------------------|------------| | Coinexx | 0.0 pips | ECN | $10 | Yes | Yes | | MidasFX | 0.0 pips | STP/ECN | $1 | Yes | Yes | | Hankotrade | 0.0 pips | ECN | $10 | Yes | Yes | | OANDA | 1.0 pips | MM | $0 | Yes | Yes | | Forex.com | 0.8 pips | STP | $100 | Yes | Yes |
Understanding Scalping Costs
Spread Cost Example
Trading EUR/USD, 1 standard lot:
- **2 pip spread**: $20 cost per trade
- **1 pip spread**: $10 cost per trade
- **0.5 pip spread**: $5 cost per trade
- **0.0 pip + $7 commission**: $7 cost per trade
If you make 20 trades per day:
- 2 pip spread = $400/day in costs
- 0.0 pip + commission = $140/day in costs
The difference: $260/day or $5,200/month!
Scalping Tips
1. Trade During High Liquidity
- London/NY overlap (8 AM - 12 PM EST)
- Spreads tightest during active sessions
2. Use Limit Orders When Possible
- Avoid slippage
- Better entry prices
3. Focus on Major Pairs
- EUR/USD, GBP/USD, USD/JPY
- Tightest spreads, best execution
4. Test Execution First
- Use demo account
- Measure actual execution speed
- Check for requotes
Brokers to Avoid for Scalping
Watch out for:
- Brokers with "no scalping" in terms
- Wide spreads (2+ pips on EUR/USD)
- Frequent requotes
- Slow execution (500ms+)
- Dealing desk brokers with conflict of interest
Our Top Pick
For US Scalpers: Hankotrade
Hankotrade offers the best combination of:
- True ECN execution
- 0.0 pip raw spreads
- No scalping restrictions
- Fast execution
- Low minimum deposit
The only downside is crypto-only deposits and offshore regulation. If you need a regulated option, OANDA or Forex.com are solid alternatives.
---
*Risk Warning: Scalping is high-risk, high-frequency trading. Most retail traders lose money. Only risk capital you can afford to lose.*
The Complete US Forex Trading Checklist
Everything you need to verify before depositing your first dollar. Covers broker selection, CFTC compliance, account setup, and risk management.
